Category Archives: Libraries

From Blog Post to Publication: The Evolution of an Idea

Recently, a revised version of one of my blog posts was published. Much to my surprise, it has been widely distributed and read. Since the likelihood of another one of my blog posts having this reach is probably zero, I wanted to take this opportunity to trace the evolution of the post and its success.

As regular readers know, this past summer, I spent a week at the Filson Historical Society. While waiting for some folders to be pulled one afternoon, one of the curators, Sarah-Jane Poindexter, and I discussed the disconnect between archivists and academics. That conversation and the State of Tennessee’s decision to cut hours and staff at the Tennessee State Library and Archives prompted me to write a blog post of appreciation for the numerous librarians and archivists who had helped me over the years.

David Loiterstein at Readex contacted me the day after the post appeared and asked if I would consider letting Readex publish a revised version of the blog post in its newsletter. I agreed, and it appeared in The Readex Report e-newsletter in mid-November.

The piece has since been widely shared via Twitter, Facebook, e-mail, and blogs, including Stephen Abram’s blog and the AHA blog. I have had librarians and archivists with whom I’ve worked and several whom I’ve never met thank me for the post. This has been one of the most satisfying things that has happened in my professional life.

Lest you think I’m just pumping my own tires here, this response also was completely unexpected. I’ve written blog posts that I thought were excellent research summaries or thought-provoking analyses of contemporary problems that received only a handful of page views, while this post, which was simply a self-reflective piece about my interactions with other professionals, has probably had a much larger reach and influence than anything else I’ve ever written.

The lesson is one of unintended (and in this case, pleasant) consequences. Expressing genuine appreciation to colleagues is sometimes hard for academics to do, but, trust me, you’ll enjoy the warm feeling it gives you, and you just might make someone else’s day.


In Praise of Librarians and Archivists

Since I was a child begging my mother to take me to the library on a daily basis, I have appreciated the designated keepers of books. Conducting research as a student made me even more aware of the specialized jobs that academic librarians and archivists do every day to make life easier for people like me.

Partly because of that background, Meredith Farkas’ recent post struck a nerve. This particular sentence caught my eye:

We need to go back to a model where scholarly publishing is about providing access to scholarship . . .

It reminded me of a conversation that I had with an archivist earlier this year. This individual argued that the turf wars between academics (history professors such as myself) and archivists harmed the scholarly pursuit.  Archives need to be open and accessible to the public, which was one of my rallying cries earlier this year about the Tennessee State Library and Archives. At the same time, academics do not possess a proprietary right to sources that they are using. For example, if a family genealogist is using a source at an archive that I need for my academic research, or if an archive has restricted access to a collection, it is not my right to demand that my research takes priority or that the rules don’t apply to me. (You laugh, but I’ve seen both happen.)

It’s also a shame that academics sometimes view library and archival staff as people to do their bidding instead of partners in scholarship. Believe me, library and archival staff have helped me immensely over the years, identifying sources that might be useful, finding extra funding for books that I needed for upcoming courses, and ordering obscure interlibrary loan requests. Without them, I would never have finished my undergraduate degree, graduate school, or my first book, nor would my students have had the access that they needed to do the work required.

So, for all of you librarians and archivists who’ve helped me and others over the years, thank you. You don’t get enough credit (or pay) for what you do.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 838 other followers